Comics and cartoons are great ways to engage students in learning. Think about those students who love graphic novels. Did you know that there are sites out there that actually let you, yes you create your vey own cartoon and comic strips? I experimented with ToonDoo, Pixton, and MakeBeliefsComix and here is what I thought about them.
ToonDoo is a free illustrating service that allows users to create and share comic strips. After creating my account, came the task of creating my very first comic strip. I started my comic by first choosing a character. It took forever for the characters to load, I literally waited almost 10 minutes or longer. I eventually logged out and restarted. Once I was able to actually create my comic strip, it was some what easy to create. * Note that you have a variety of options to choose from backgrounds, movements, text boxes, etc. Because it was my very first, I wanted to create something simple. I would not recommend this site when working with students, it just takes too much time, and I only have so much time to work with students.
MakeBeliefsComix After a few attempts of trying to go to the site MakeBeliefComix from my computer, I kept getting the message below that my antivirus ware was picking up a possible threat from this site. I used a different computer, once I did, I went back to the site, and whalaa...I was able to create the comic strip below, with ease. I didn't have to create an account or anything. I love that. I can see students enjoying and using this site easily! It's free and no account is needed.
I'm not going to say I didn't enjoy this assignment, because the whole idea of me creating a comic strip was exciting. However, I found the first two sites somewhat tedious to work with (maybe because it was my first time), and considering the amount of time I have to work with students each day, I'm not sure about using or recommending either of them? But, I did like the finished product. After, getting a chance to finally create a comic strip on MakeBeliefComix, the process was so easy for me. I would recommend it out of the three for students and teachers . One way I might incorporate comic strips in the future is by organizing a graphic novel book discussion or teaching students to make their own comic strips. Enjoy!
I agree with you on the time it will take for Toondoo. It is very busy, but I like it for older students.
ReplyDeleteMake Beliefs Comix was the easiest for me as well and in my opinion more user friendly. I had the same problem with ToonDoo, ugh frustrating. I imagine it'll take just as long on the school's servers (although I did not try it). I did like it, but the loading problems caused me frustration.
ReplyDeleteI also thought of using it for novel books discussions. I think students would really enjoy it. I also like Pixton and the many features it had to offer.
Time is always a consideration! And I was also wondering about diversity with these comics. Do you think there is enough representation for folks with disabilities as well as ethnicity and gender? Here's another resource I found: https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Web_2.0_and_Emerging_Learning_Technologies/ToonDoo.
ReplyDeleteI had the same problem with MakeBeliefComix too. It wouldn't work the first day I tried it and was blocked, etc. Then the next day I tried again, it worked great and is my first choice to use with my students too.
ReplyDelete